The Algoma softball team had eight players make Packerland All-Conference teams for the 2019 season led by conference player of the year Maddy Prokash. She made the first team as a pitcher. Prokash was joined on the first team by catcher Makayla Giulette and outfielder Miss Srnka. Chlole Spitzer and Emersyn Wallace were named second teamers as infielders and Hanna Weise as an outfielder. Brooklyn Hoffmann (IF) and Breanne Schmidt (OF) were named Honorable Mention players.

Zach Schmidt was the only Wolf on the baseball team to be named to an all-conference team. He made second team as a pitcher.